|
|
| Author |
Message |
MP mulattoprince Wizard

Joined: 10 Apr 2007 {Posts: 464 }
|
Posted: Wed 13 Aug 2008 12:27 Post subject: |
|
|
| Whites one drop out of tradition, and it is very beneficial for them to. Because it allows them to have more power culturally with out having to worry about a third race. When you are put under the ODR it makes it easier to control you because blacks will help police you. This benefits whites, and makes mulattoes have to live according to semi predictable out comes. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
chip Experienced User

Joined: 24 Sep 2008 {Posts: 102 } Location: Santiago, DR
|
Posted: Wed 08 Oct 2008 17:56 Post subject: |
|
|
| MP mulattoprince wrote: | | Because it allows them to have more power culturally with out having to worry about a third race. |
Really, what about Hispanics and Asians???
| MP mulattoprince wrote: | | When you are put under the ODR it makes it easier to control you because blacks will help police you. |
Could you explain this a little more clearly please?
| MP mulattoprince wrote: | | This benefits whites, and makes mulattoes have to live according to semi predictable out comes. |
What might those be? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
girlfromthenc Mentor

Joined: 27 Nov 2004 {Posts: 214 }
|
Posted: Thu 09 Oct 2008 00:33 Post subject: |
|
|
| MP mulattoprince wrote: | | Whites one drop out of tradition, and it is very beneficial for them to. Because it allows them to have more power culturally with out having to worry about a third race. When you are put under the ODR it makes it easier to control you because blacks will help police you. This benefits whites, and makes mulattoes have to live according to semi predictable out comes. |
I have always found that White and Black Americans share similar views on race with each (maybe its bit of a reaction to one another) and that Whites are 2x more uncomfortable with the idea of Multiracial identities than Blacks. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Powell Guru

Joined: 27 Nov 2004 {Posts: 2140 }
|
Posted: Thu 09 Oct 2008 12:57 Post subject: Whites and the ODR |
|
|
| girlfromthenc wrote: | | MP mulattoprince wrote: | | Whites one drop out of tradition, and it is very beneficial for them to. Because it allows them to have more power culturally with out having to worry about a third race. When you are put under the ODR it makes it easier to control you because blacks will help police you. This benefits whites, and makes mulattoes have to live according to semi predictable out comes. |
I have always found that White and Black Americans share similar views on race with each (maybe its bit of a reaction to one another) and that Whites are 2x more uncomfortable with the idea of Multiracial identities than Blacks. |
I've found it to be quite the opposite. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
fwsweet Administrator

Joined: 26 Nov 2004 {Posts: 4537 } Location: Palm Coast, FL
|
Posted: Thu 09 Oct 2008 13:22 Post subject: Re: Whites and the ODR |
|
|
| girlfromthenc wrote: | | I have always found that White and Black Americans share similar views on race with each (maybe its bit of a reaction to one another) and that Whites are 2x more uncomfortable with the idea of Multiracial identities than Blacks. |
| Powell wrote: | | I've found it to be quite the opposite. |
You may be talking about different flavors of "Whites." It makes sense that those who strongly self-identify as White, like those who strongly self-identify as Black will want everyone to choose one side or the other. But those merely seen as White (or Black), and yet who when asked have no problem acknowledging mixed ancestry in themselves, will be more tolerant of people who refuse to choose sides. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
G-Man Moderator

Joined: 27 Nov 2004 {Posts: 2612 }
|
Posted: Thu 09 Oct 2008 16:29 Post subject: |
|
|
| girlfromthenc wrote: |
I have always found that White and Black Americans share similar views on race with each (maybe its bit of a reaction to one another) and that Whites are 2x more uncomfortable with the idea of Multiracial identities than Blacks. |
Depends on what you mean by uncomfortable with the idea of multiracial identities.
Drawing on my own experience, whites are more uncomfortable with the possibility that they may have other ancestries, specifically African more than any other. I’ve encountered whites who’ve gotten pretty irate when you mention that they could have African ancestry.
Blacks on the other hand generally have no problem acknowledging other ancestries.
The two deviate when it comes to an actual multiracial identity distinct from an either black or white one for someone with African ancestry. In that case, blacks are more uncomfortable than whites. Whites are largely indifferent. They’ll either continue seeing the person as black or non-white, but will not evince more discomfort for such an individual compared to someone who is black-identified.
Naturally, there are exceptions. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
chip Experienced User

Joined: 24 Sep 2008 {Posts: 102 } Location: Santiago, DR
|
Posted: Thu 09 Oct 2008 18:10 Post subject: |
|
|
As far as I know I'm just a typical white guy from the South, yet I wouldn't have any problem whatsoever if I had African roots. Honestly, when you get down to it we all trace our lineage to Africa anyway, so what in the world is the big deal.
It is even possible that we have some black in our family on my father's mother side, because she was of olive skin even though she was considered white. Her sister(my favorite Aunt) was even darker and had curly black hair.
On a related topic, I'm married to a mixed black women now and if we ever separate I would never marry another "pure" race women, in fact I wouldn't pick one unless she had at least some african blood in her - does that make me a "one dropper" then?  |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
girlfromthenc Mentor

Joined: 27 Nov 2004 {Posts: 214 }
|
Posted: Thu 09 Oct 2008 22:09 Post subject: |
|
|
| G-Man wrote: | | girlfromthenc wrote: | | I have always found that White and Black Americans share similar views on race with each (maybe its bit of a reaction to one another) and that Whites are 2x more uncomfortable with the idea of Multiracial identities than Blacks. |
Depends on what you mean by uncomfortable with the idea of multiracial identities.
Drawing on my own experience, whites are more uncomfortable with the possibility that they may have other ancestries, specifically African more than any other. I’ve encountered whites who’ve gotten pretty irate when you mention that they could have African ancestry.
Blacks on the other hand generally have no problem acknowledging other ancestries.
The two deviate when it comes to an actual multiracial identity distinct from an either black or white one for someone with African ancestry. In that case, blacks are more uncomfortable than whites. Whites are largely indifferent. They’ll either continue seeing the person as black or non-white, but will not evince more discomfort for such an individual compared to someone who is black-identified.
Naturally, there are exceptions. |
I wish I could agree but can't. I've heard too many Whites make odd remarks about someone being "black". I' don't count the internet because people are normally extra bold since its not face to face. But one such time was my last year in college and I had this White roommate. Her boyfriend and her were watching American idol and that kid Justin Guarini comes on to sing.http://img2.timeinc.net/people/i/2007/specials/americanidolgallery/justin_guarini.jpg
sing! Anybody who use to follow the season of American Idol he was on knew that his mother was White (Italian I think) and his real father was Black/AA but his mother and father weren't together and his step father (white) was who showed up to support him during the show. Well I suppose my wonderful roommate and her boyfriend saw his mother and father and her boyfriend asked what race was he suppose to be? My roommate blurts out 'he's BLACK!' Look at his hair" like his hair was the grossiest thing she'd ever seen! After she declared him black, they didn't argue over his race any longer. I don't know if it was because they suddenly remembered I was in the room or after carefully studying his hair they came to the conclusion she was right and he really was Black.
She was one of the more vocal ones. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
G-Man Moderator

Joined: 27 Nov 2004 {Posts: 2612 }
|
Posted: Sun 12 Oct 2008 01:18 Post subject: |
|
|
From the story one white simply saw him as black. It wasn't clear from your story that they displayed discomfort with him as someone who identified as multiracial. I’m not even sure he made an issue of his background on the show.
As I read it, the boyfriend displayed more uncertainty as to what he really was as opposed to hostility at his ambiguity. The girlfriend seemed sure he must have been black, which was the default classification for her.
BTW, isn’t Guarini related to Samuel Jackson? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
sagascend Moderator

Joined: 17 Jun 2006 {Posts: 2087 }
|
Posted: Tue 21 Oct 2008 19:05 Post subject: |
|
|
A couple of weeks ago when I was in Chicago, a group of young women (probably 23-27) were walking by me. I heard one of them describing a friend by saying something to the effect of "Yeah she looks White but she isn't. She's got something else in her." Eyeballing them, they looked like Euro American farm girls from the Midwest, people that would be labeled "White" in the U.S. This isn't the first time I have heard White folks onedropping and it will be far from the last time.
Now I have no idea whether they were discussing a genetically mixed individual of partial SSA, Asian or NA descent, but this statement is totally nonsensical anywhere but in the U.S. Both Blacks and Whites in the U.S. make sense of this idea on a daily basis. I see no reason to conclude that Whites do not one drop and haven't seen persuasive evidence to conclude that Blacks onedrop more. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
chip Experienced User

Joined: 24 Sep 2008 {Posts: 102 } Location: Santiago, DR
|
Posted: Tue 21 Oct 2008 19:57 Post subject: |
|
|
I am of course aware of one dropping by whites, growing up in the South. However, it wasn't extensive as many people may believe. Truth be told that this might be mitigated by the fact that I never ran with the popular crowd for numerous reason, some of it due to my Catholic beliefs and others because somehow I was "unfit" to be invited in.
Before I had come across this forum, I was not really sure if I even heard or knew what one dropping meant. I do remember that there was the girl in high school, that even though she was "white", she had some multiracial features like super kinky hair and full lips and a skin color that was different from Europen "white". Needless to say, I had a crush on her as she was quite attractive. On a side note, she ran with the in crowd, something I never could do - so I never considered approaching her being the wimp I was.
I really have come to the conclusion that only intermarrying will do away with the blight of racism. Over time like in other countries it will no longer be a big deal. Also the fact that mixed race people are arguably some of the most handsome of God's people (excuse my apparent prejudice) should help expedite the process as they become more and more numerous. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
gemini072 Moderator

Joined: 27 Nov 2004 {Posts: 2678 }
|
Posted: Tue 21 Oct 2008 23:33 Post subject: |
|
|
| chip wrote: | I am of course aware of one dropping by whites, growing up in the South. However, it wasn't extensive as many people may believe. Truth be told that this might be mitigated by the fact that I never ran with the popular crowd for numerous reason, some of it due to my Catholic beliefs and others because somehow I was "unfit" to be invited in.
Before I had come across this forum, I was not really sure if I even heard or knew what one dropping meant. I do remember that there was the girl in high school, that even though she was "white", she had some multiracial features like super kinky hair and full lips and a skin color that was different from Europen "white". Needless to say, I had a crush on her as she was quite attractive. On a side note, she ran with the in crowd, something I never could do - so I never considered approaching her being the wimp I was.
I really have come to the conclusion that only intermarrying will do away with the blight of racism. Over time like in other countries it will no longer be a big deal. Also the fact that mixed race people are arguably some of the most handsome of God's people (excuse my apparent prejudice) should help expedite the process as they become more and more numerous. |
I brought up something in a different post about whites onedropping in different ways. They don't all do it openly and bluntly as in sayin '1 drop makes u black' it's in other ways... it comes through stereotypes, racial assumptions. The language is just different.
An example. At the office last week a young intern from the UofR is working in the IT dept of our company. He came to see about an issue I had with my computer log on. One of the white guys came in and asked "Is that my brother" Now, this kid looks nothing like me, nothing at all, not only is he like200lbs he facially does not even come close to resembling me, and his skin completion is very dark(I said dark last because mixed people can have dark and light siblings). Well spoke young man and intellegence are probably our only similarities.
They assumption that out of all the AA, Mixed, African descendant people not only in the country, but in the state, in the city and in the company, this kid must be my brother, tells a lot of how white people communicate the ODR.
Another example, there is a young PR kid who is a seasonal worker, who outside of you knowing is name, there is nothing "Puerto Rican" about him, even his girlfriend is black. Him and I have commented on how much we look alike: skin complexion, hair texture, facial features. A female (english descendant) joined a conversation we were having about our similarities and she stated that I looked black, and he looks Puerto Rican. That wasn't an written in stone "1 Drop Rule" statement...she didn't say well Ty the ODR says your black. And as ADPowell has pointed out the hypocracy in who a latino with the same visual mixture would not get 1 Dropped as this one did not do to him, She communicated stronly the ODR. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
girlfromthenc Mentor

Joined: 27 Nov 2004 {Posts: 214 }
|
Posted: Thu 23 Oct 2008 00:18 Post subject: |
|
|
I think Hispanics of obvious African descent are not called Blacks because most Americans see them as neither Black nor White. I've seen similar situations where obviously European looking Latinos are explained as being of "Hispanic origin" and right beside it there's a White American woman described as being of "Caucasian descent".
But G-man brought up a very good observation I noticed too. This Central American versus Carribbean Latino rift. The Mexicans at my former job use to do this same thing as well. Two of them told me that they thought I was "Puerto Rican". I found that strange because most Puerto Ricans I have seen were quite light skinned and only one I've met had coarse hair. I found out some time later that all Latinos that are considered mixed or Black looking are often questioned whether they are Puerto Ricans including many Afro-Mexicans. I had one Mexican guy question me about Beyonce really being African-American. He kept asking me if I was sure. I kept saying "yes, everybody knows this". He keeps looking at me like he doesn't believe me and telling me that he thinks she's Puerto Rican. Again, I wanted to know where he was meeting all these Black looking kinky haired Puerto Ricans at . Many PRs are Whiter looking than him.
As G-man got at earlier, I think many Central Americans have got it in their heads that Puerto Ricans and Dominicans are the only Latinos mixed with Blacks. Cubans I've noticed are normally exempt by other Hispanics because light skin Cubans got out of their way to draw the line between Black and White Cubans. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
gemini072 Moderator

Joined: 27 Nov 2004 {Posts: 2678 }
|
Posted: Thu 23 Oct 2008 01:16 Post subject: |
|
|
| girlfromthenc wrote: | I think Hispanics of obvious African descent are not called Blacks because most Americans see them as neither Black nor White. I've seen similar situations where obviously European looking Latinos are explained as being of "Hispanic origin" and right beside it there's a White American woman described as being of "Caucasian descent".
But G-man brought up a very good observation I noticed too. This Central American versus Carribbean Latino rift. The Mexicans at my former job use to do this same thing as well. Two of them told me that they thought I was "Puerto Rican". I found that strange because most Puerto Ricans I have seen were quite light skinned and only one I've met had coarse hair. I found out some time later that all Latinos that are considered mixed or Black looking are often questioned whether they are Puerto Ricans including many Afro-Mexicans. I had one Mexican guy question me about Beyonce really being African-American. He kept asking me if I was sure. I kept saying "yes, everybody knows this". He keeps looking at me like he doesn't believe me and telling me that he thinks she's Puerto Rican. Again, I wanted to know where he was meeting all these Black looking kinky haired Puerto Ricans at . Many PRs are Whiter looking than him.
As G-man got at earlier, I think many Central Americans have got it in their heads that Puerto Ricans and Dominicans are the only Latinos mixed with Blacks. Cubans I've noticed are normally exempt by other Hispanics because light skin Cubans got out of their way to draw the line between Black and White Cubans. |
That's interesting
I know of and have met a good number of PR who you would think were AA. And I alway run across Puerto Ricans that, by the visuals you would think just came from Nigeria or the Ivory Coast.
It actually happened the other day, a black worker from another dept came to do some work on the HVAC. This guy was AA from first look, quick glance he was AA, long stare he was AA... until he opened his mouth and introduced himself. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|